Although loss framing is expected to be the most persuasive, we also suppose that non gain framing will be slightly more effective than gain framing. The effects frames on preferences are compared to the effects of perspectives perceptual appear ance. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. When, how and why is lossframing more effective than gain. Strategic use of gain and lossframed messages to promote. As a result, people tend to be more motivated to avoid losses than they are to achieve comparable gains. The dependence of preferences on the formulation decision problems is a significant concern for the theory of rational choice. When, how and why is lossframing more effective than gain and nongainframing in the promotion of detection behaviors. However, little is known about the underlying mechanisms behind framing effects. However, consistent with the objective of the study, differences emerged on specific manipulation check items.
If a situation is framed as one in which a participant is given the opportunity to reduce a possible loss by cheating. The loss of the status quo is thought to loom larger than the gain of a change option loss and gain are confounded with inaction and action. Another property of the value function is that the response to losses is more extreme than the re sponse to gains. The same relation be tween value differences holds for the corresponding losses. We study gainloss framing in binary modified dictator games.
Prospect theory is an economic theory which tries to describe the way people will behave when given choices which involve probability. The role of message framing in promoting mmr vaccination. How they frame those judgments affects the attractiveness of the purchase. Extending research and theory on negotiator frame the conceptualization of outcomes as gains or as losses this study assumes that a negotiators often have foreknowledge about their opponent. Gainloss framing definition gain or loss framing refers to phrasing a statement that describes a choice or outcome in terms of its positive gain or negative loss features. Based on prospect theory, the present study investigated gain vs. The role of message framing in hotel guests recycling behaviour. Two types of framing, known as gain framing and loss framing, are common but must be used correctly when. When, how and why is lossframing more effective than. The impact of gain and lossframed messages on young.
Given the premise that people are more willing to take risks when faced with lossframed information but are more risk averse when. Pdf the use of gain or lossframe messages and efficacy. One hundred and forty women read either a lossframed or. Weight gain or weight loss decreased immune system increased anxiety or panic attacks dreams of the deceased. Comparing gain and lossframed messages for smoking. Underlying his gainloss proposition was the suggestion that developmental change at all ages entails elements of gain growth and elements of loss. Of three clear methods of framing risky choices, kahneman and tverskys.
Messages that frame a target behavior in terms of its benefits gain frame or costs loss frame have been widely and successfully used for health promotion and risk reduction. The use of gain or lossframe messages and efficacy appeals to dissuade excessive alcohol consumption among college students. In his 1972 social psychology textbook, the social animal, he stated aronsons first. The strategic use of gain and lossframed messages to. Abstract this study examined the effects of message framing on intentions to obtain the measles, mumps and rubella mmr vaccine for ones child and investigated whether theory of planned behaviour tpb and perceived outcome efficacy variables mediate andor moderate message framing effects. Charlie brown, gain loss principle, mere exposure theory, mike cardwell, peppermint patty, reciprocity theory, robert cialdini. The superiority of loss over both gain and non gain framing with regards to perceived negative consequences is expected to be true only for individuals in a situation of high issuerelevance. Alternatively, removal of an invasive species may provide opportunities to avert further loss of native species. Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance.
The ratings were used to estimatefour alternative models of the lottery evaluationprocess. The advantages of compliance or the disadvantages of. Prospect theory assumes that individuals make decisions based on expectations of loss or gain from their current relative position. This plan will save one of the three plants and 2,000 jobs. The extent to which reference framing effects in negotiations are caused by loss aversion or the risk shift remains an open question. Results demonstrated that a gainframed message was the most persuasive in promoting the screening test aimed to detect the enzyme described as conferring excellent health. People will have the best chance of having a life without skin cancer. Although lossframing is expected to be the most persuasive, we also suppose that nongainframing will be slightly more effective than gainframing. How such messages are framed affects patients perception of the content and how effective the message will be in making a difference. Rothman and salovey 1997 proposed that predictions regarding the relative influence of gain and lossframed messages on health behavior can be derived from the conceptual framework outlined in prospect theory. Expectations regarding how people will react to gain and loss messages are rooted in prospect theory 14,23. Former fbi negotiator chris voss at the australia real estate conference duration. They like me, they really like me in psychology of success, success on june 30, 2009 at 6.
Subjects choose the selfish option more often in the loss frame compared to the gain frame. The field experiment tests the moderating effect of message construal level concrete or abstract on the message frame that. Pharmacists and other health care providers often use persuasive messages to promote health behavior change. Pdf the use of message framing in the promotion of. Elliot aronson born january 9, 1932 is an american psychologist who has carried out experiments on the theory of cognitive dissonance, and invented the jigsaw classroom, a cooperative teaching technique which facilitates learning while reducing interethnic hostility and prejudice. The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. Based on the assumption that the loss frame induces higher motivation to reduce the loss than does the gain frame to increase the gain, we investigate the following hypothesis. Gainframed appeals are more effective when targeting behaviors that prevent the onset of disease, whereas lossframed appeals are more effective. A lossframe is when you focus on the costs or the loss, such as opportunity cost. The key thing to keep in mind is that we do more to avoid pain, than to seek gain, and that we prefer more certain outcomes than uncertain alternatives. The framing implications of prospect theory suggest that individuals respond differently to factually equivalent messages depending on whether they are framed so as to. This loss frame highlights the ability of environmental managers to prevent further degradation of the natural ecosystem. In recent decades, there has been an increase in the use of negative imaging that is, a lossframed approach to promote smoking cessation.
The lossframe advantage for illnessdetection behaviors is a somewhat more reliable effect, as in rothman et al. Participants demonstrated similar smoking cessation knowledge scores across the two conditions gainframe. Gain framegain frame loss frameloss frame plan a plan b plan c plan d cbs 2009 57 43 50 50 different frames, same alternatives. Prospect theory and the research on framing effect would predict that a loss frame would result in the most significant behavior change. The superiority of loss over both gain and nongainframing with regards to perceived negative consequences is expected to be true only for individuals in a situation of high issuerelevance. Results from the structural model revealed no association between a perceived threat to.
The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice amos. However, the impact of framed messages on decisions to have sex and sexual risk, as well as moderators of these effects, has remained largely unexplored. Effects of gainloss frames on satisfaction with self. Examining the role of message frame, perceived risk, and ambivalence in the decision to become an organ donor. Prospect theory suggests that the pain of losing is about twice as strong as the joy of gaining the same amount. This study specifically assessed how the framing effect would be moderated by the gender of message recipients and their fear arousal. In the health communication field, prospect theory has been extensively applied over the. Recording visual fixations with eyetracking, we find that dictators focus more on their. The overall advantage was found, though the effect was disturbingly small r. Since losses loom larger than gains, it appears that humans follow conservative strategies when presented with a positivelyframed dilemma, and risky strategies when presented with negatively. To illustrate this effect, grounded in prospect theory, ask yourself which of the following two gasoline stations youd be more willing to patronize, assuming that you deem both brands to be equally good and you would always pay with a credit card. Simultaneously, there is a noticeable dearth in gainframed advertising positivelyframed messages that urge for the same change in behavior. The use of gain or lossframe messages and efficacy.
668 566 602 1645 1193 1413 1112 920 160 794 358 1312 1044 1405 1158 758 909 737 664 1663 1625 435 1252 204 1634 1394 323 712 985 1341 247 431 1040 362 9 264 36 1270 1193 1455 986 89 593 820